Monday, August 4, 2014

CBO Letter to Senator Hatch About Various Options for Payroll Taxes and Social Security

 

Senator Orrin Hatch asked CBO several questions about the implications of altering the Social Security payroll tax rates as well as the taxable maximum (the maximum amount of earnings on which those payroll taxes are imposed). This document provides CBO’s answers to those questions.

For the various options discussed, CBO presents the changes that would result in the annual payroll taxes paid by employees and employers, and for people born at various times and with various levels of earnings, the change in their median lifetime payroll taxes and median initial replacement rates (benefits as a percentage of career-average earnings).

CBO based its answers on projections issued last September in The 2013 Long-Term Budget Outlook. In that report, the 75-year projection period for Social Security spans 2013 to 2087. All changes to payroll tax rates and the taxable maximum analyzed for this report would begin in January 2015.

Read Complete Document  (pdf, 212 kb)

Read more!

Testimony from Social Security Subcommittee Hearing on “What Workers Need to Know About Social Security as They Plan for Their Retirement.”

Chairman Johnson Announces Hearing on What Workers Need to Know About Social Security as They Plan for Their Retirement
B-318 Rayburn House Office Building at 11:00 AM

Jul 29, 2014
Focus Of The Hearing
The hearing will focus on the financial status of Social Security programs, the factors influencing the benefits paid, the status of Americans’ retirement readiness and how workers can be helped to better plan for their retirement.   
Hearing Advisory
Chairman Johnson Announces Hearing on What Workers Need to Know About Social Security as They Plan for Their Retirement
Witness List
Charles P. Blahous III, Ph.D.
Public Trustee, Social Security and Medicare Boards of Trustees
Testimony
(Truth in Testimony)
Sylvester J. Schieber, Ph.D.
Independent Consultant
Testimony
(Truth in Testimony) 
C. Eugene Steuerle, Ph.D.
Institute Fellow and Richard B. Fischer Chair, Urban Institute
Testimony
(Truth in Testimony) 
Joan Entmacher
Vice President for Family Economic Security, National Women’s Law Center
Testimony
(Truth in Testimony) 
Andrew G. Biggs, Ph.D.
Resident Scholar, American Enterprise Institute
Testimony
(Truth in Testimony) 
Laurence J. Kotlikoff, Ph.D.
William Fairfield Warren Professor, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts
Testimony
(Truth in Testimony)

Read more!

Chuck Blahous’s Guide to the 2014 Social Security Trustees Report

From Social Security Public Trustee Charles Blahous:

Today e21 published my guide to the latest Social Security trustees’ report (the full report can be found here, a summary here, and a video of our press conference here). The following day I testified on the report (my testimony here and video here). The Social Security report is one of two such annual reports, the other covering Medicare, which I will summarize in my next piece for e21.

Excerpts from today’s summary: 

Social Security’s Disability Insurance Fund Faces Depletion in 2016: The DI fund is projected to be depleted in two years, in the fourth quarter of 2016. Unless the law is changed disability payments will drop suddenly by 19 percent. Some have suggested the impending DI fund depletion is appropriately handled by reallocating taxes between Social Security’s trust funds. This suggests a misdiagnosis. OASI actually faces a bigger shortfall than DI. The main reason DI is hitting the wall first is that the baby boomers are moving through their years of peak DI incidence before converting to retirement. While lawmakers may include interfund borrowing or a temporary tax reallocation as part of a comprehensive solution it would be counterproductive to enact either as a standalone policy, if it served to facilitate continued delay of needed reforms.

Social Security’s Financing Shortfall May Soon Be Insolubly Large: The shortfall has grown far beyond its size during Social Security’s 1982-1983 crisis. It was then saved from insolvency by a last-moment bipartisan rescue. The measures required were intensely controversial.  We are already at a point where an agreement would require the left to accept benefit restraints roughly twice as large as in 1983, and the right to accept tax increases twice as large—unless either gives even more ground. There is no assurance of such an agreement. If the problem grows politically insoluble, Social Security’s financing structure must eventually be abandoned. This would most likely require permanent financing from the general fund. Gone would be the program’s contribution-benefit link, and the conception of Social Security as an “earned benefit.”

The Problem Reflects an Excess of Obligations to Those Already in the System: As this table shows the shortfall consists entirely of an excess of scheduled benefits over contributions for people already in the system, not from any inadequacy of contributions by future workers. To the contrary, those now entering the workforce stand to pay far more than they will receive—by 4.4 percent of wages—irrespective of whether the system is balanced by assessing them with higher taxes or lower scheduled benefits. The only way to prevent these income losses for younger generations is to slow benefit growth for those already in the system.

We Didn’t Much Change our Long-term Outlook, but the Short-term Problem is More Urgent: We made only minor changes to our long-term assumptions.

We Made Some Presentational Improvements: We changed our benefit illustrations to eliminate confusion caused by earlier reports. Many had misinterpreted these as indicating that “benefits replace about 40 percent of preretirement earnings” on average when this was not the comparison made.  Lacking a universally agreed-upon method of calculating replacement rates, we simply removed the misunderstood measure.

Overall, this year’s report shows us a critical year closer to a Social Security financing crisis, with the certainty of its resolution increasingly in doubt.

Read more!

Tuesday, July 22, 2014

Upcoming event: “Decoding the 2014 Social Security Trustees Report”

CRFB letterhead logo

Decoding the 2014 Social Security Trustees Report

 

Tuesday, July 29, 2014

8:30 am - 10:30 am

Hyatt Regency

400 New Jersey Avenue NW

Washington, DC 20002   

Please RSVP

Breakfast Will Be Served

Please join the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget for breakfast, presentation, and a panel discussion on the 2014 Social Security Trustees Report and the future of the Social Security program.

The event will feature a presentation from Stephen Goss, Chief Actuary of the Social Security Administration, and a bipartisan panel discussion. The panel will feature a variety of perspectives and provide a timely and informative discussion about the 2014 Social Security Trustees report, the Social Security program, and what Washington should do to reform the program in the coming years.

Please RSVP to join us on July 29.

Agenda

8:30 am       Registration and Breakfast

9:00 am       Understanding the Trustees Report

Stephen Goss, Chief Actuary of the Social Security Program

Remarks by:

  • Congressman Tom Cole (R-OK)
  • Congressman John Delaney (D-MD)*

9:30 am       Panel Discussion: Is It Time to Reform Social Security?

Moderated by Damian Paletta, The Wall Street Journal

  • Andrew Biggs, Resident Scholar, American Enterprise Institute
  • Jason Fichtner, Senior Research Fellow, Mercatus Center at George Mason University
  • Stephen Goss, Chief Actuary of the Social Security Program
  • Jim Kessler, Senior Vice President and Co-Founder, Third Way
  • Paul Van de Water, Senior Fellow, Center on Budget & Policy Priorities

  And be sure to follow the conversation on Twitter:

#SocialSecurity

@budgethawks, @damianpaletta, @thirdwaykessler, @AEIecon, @JJFichtner, @SocialSecurity, @CenterOnBudget

*invited

Read more!

Friday, July 18, 2014

Millennials not counting on Social Security

Investors Business Daily reports on an opinion poll from the Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies. The Millennial generation isn’t exactly counting on Social Security to take care of them in retirement, and instead have (or report having) begun saving for retirement themselves, at rates Transamerica claims are surprisingly high.

Check out the whole story for details.

Read more!

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Presentations from NASI Social Security Academy

Demystifying Social Security: 2014 Summer Academy

Wednesday, July 9, 2014
Kaiser Family Foundation ■ Barbara Jordan Conference Center
1330 G Street, NW ■ Washington, DC
#SocSec14

8:30 AM REGISTRATION / LIGHT BREAKFAST

9:00 AM WELCOME

  • Jill Braunstein, National Academy of Social Insurance

9:15 AM OPENING SESSION - Why is Social Security Important?
Why is Social Security relevant and important to younger generations.

  • Donna Butts, Generations United
  • Jeff Cruz, Office of Senator Elizabeth Warren​​​
  • Moderator: Ilana Mittleman, 2014 NASI Summer Intern

9:45 AM SESSION I - Social Security: How Does it Work?
Social Security is a multifaceted program with a variety of benefits. Who receives benefits? How important are Social Security benefits for the people who receive them? What is Social Security Disability Insurance?

  • Kathleen Romig (PDF), Social Security Administration and Social Security Advisory Board
  • T.J. Sutcliffe (PDF), The Arc
  • Mikki Waid (PDF), AARP Public Policy Institute
  • Moderator: Ismael Cid, 2014 NASI Summer Intern

10:50 AM BREAK/NETWORKING

11:05 AM SESSION II - Straight Talk on Social Security's Financing and Policy Options
Who pays for Social Security? What are the Social Security trust funds and why do they matter? What is the program’s financial outlook in the near term and the long term? What are some policy options to strengthen Social Security?

  • Karen Glenn (PDF), Social Security Administration
  • Stephen C. Goss (PDF), Chief Actuary, Social Security Administration
  • Elisa A. Walker (PDF), National Academy of Social Insurance
  • Moderator: Katherine Richard, 2014 NASI Summer Intern

12:00 LUNCH

12:30 SESSION III - Unfiltered: Two Visions for Social Security's Future
The Social Security program has been debated since its inception. This session will explore two different perspectives on the current state of the program and its future.

  • Marc Goldwein (PDF), Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget
  • Alex Lawson (PDF), Social Security Works
  • Moderator: Laurel Beedon, GAO

1:30 PM  BREAK/NETWORKING

1:45 PM POLICY EXERCISE (PART A) - Building Your Solution for Social Security
Experts have debated solutions to Social Security’s financing for years. What solutions would you choose to solve the issues of solvency and adequacy of Social Security?

  • Moderator: Elisa A. Walker, National Academy of Social Insurance

2:45 PM POLICY EXERCISE (PART B) - Sharing Your Solution for Social Security
Hold your own policy briefing. Report back on your plan for the future of Social Security.

  • Moderator: Ellen Skirvin, 2014 NASI Summer Intern​

3:15 PM CLOSING SESSION - Now What?: How Can I Use this Information and Experience?
Now that you have learned the ins and outs of the Social Security program, what can young people do now and throughout their careers to get involved in the policy process?

  • Kristen Arnold, National Academy of Social Insurance
  • Rebecca Vallas, Center for American Progress
  • Bethany Boland, Abt Associates
  • Moderator: Sarah Lopez, 2014 NASI Summer Intern

3:45 PM  WRAP-UP AND DOOR PRIZES

  • Josh Berman, 2014 NASI Summer Intern
Read more!

Are Social Security benefits puny? It depends how you measure them.

The Social Security Administration states that “Most financial advisors say you’ll need about 70 percent of your pre-retirement earnings to comfortably maintain your pre-retirement standard of living. Under current law, if you have average earnings, your Social Security retirement benefits will replace only about 40 percent.” Progressives cite these seemingly puny benefits in support of expanding Social Security, despite the program’s $10 trillion-plus financial shortfall.

But, as Sylvester Schieber and I show in today’s Wall Street Journal, SSA and financial advisors calculate “replacement rates” differently. If you calculated replacement rates the way financial advisors do – by comparing Social Security benefits to earnings immediately preceding retirement – the typical replacement rate for a full-career worker is around 60 percent. SSA, by contrast, compares Social Security benefits to average lifetime earnings, which is fine, but it “wage indexes” those past earnings. Wage-indexing increases your past earnings by an amount greater than the rate of inflation, in effect crediting you with earnings you never had. A retirement income is then called inadequate if it can’t replace that never-had purchasing power.

The chart below, from Schieber’s recent paper with Gaobo Pang of Towers Watson, shows five different ways of calculating Social Security replacement rates. From the left is initial Social Security benefits relative to: earnings in the 5 years before retirement; peak earnings (the 5th-9th years before retirement); the inflation-indexed average of the worker’s average lifetime earnings; and finally, the wage-indexed average of career earnings, which is how the SSA calculates replacement rates.

clip_image002

Of all the different ways of measuring replacement rates, SSA’s is by far the lowest. It also makes the least sense, since there’s nothing in the “life cycle” theory in economics or in standard financial planning in which people base their retirement saving on the growth of other people’s earnings, which is what wage-indexing does. It’s your own earnings, and smoothing your standard of living between work and retirement, that matter.

Why does SSA measure replacement rates the way it does? It’s a long story. But the short story is that we shouldn’t take it for granted that Social Security benefits fall far short of what financial planners recommend as an adequate retirement income.

Read more!